I have been thinking a lot recently about repertoire choice in terms of an ensemble’s (or for that matter a solo performer’s) relationship with themselves and with their audience. This is in part a response to a point in Blair Brown’s keynote address at LABBS Harmony College, and in part with the way it both resonated and dissonated with a conversation I had just been having with a member of Rainbow Voices. I find myself with two imperatives in play, each valid, but on the face of it in direct opposition to each other.
Blair’s comments on repertoire choice were couched in terms of personal authenticity. She recommended choosing songs with which you feel a personal connection, so that you can sing them honestly. This isn’t just about you and your comfort, however, but about your obligations to your listeners. If they are vouchsafing their attention to you, they deserve a genuine experience of human connection. Don’t put yourself in the position where you have to bullshit your audience, is how she memorably (and indeed quotably) put it.